What is a critical risk?
A critical risk is a risk associated with a hazard listed in Schedule 1A of the HSWA, or with any hazard likely to result in death, a notifiable injury or illness, a notifiable incident or an occupational disease listed in the Accident Compensation Act 2001. WorkSafe says critical risks are those likely to cause the most serious harm.
- Listed hazards: Schedule 1A points to hazards already covered by regulations, such as asbestos, hazardous substances, working at height, excavations, scaffolding, machinery, noise and cranes.
- Any other serious hazard: a hazard counts if serious harm is more than a remote possibility, judged on the worst realistic outcome.
- Likely to result: WorkSafe says this is about how likely serious harm is if something goes wrong, not how likely the event is.
For many companies the list is short. Start with the work that could kill or seriously injure someone on your sites this week. Critical risks sit inside the wider process in our guide to risk and hazard management.
Do the 2027 HSWA changes affect how I manage critical risks?
Yes. From 1 April 2027 the Health and Safety at Work Amendment Act 2026 makes critical risks the first priority for every PCBU. Companies with fewer than 20 workers for at least 9 months of a financial year have core duties focused on critical risks, so identifying and controlling them well matters more, not less.
- 20 or more workers: manage all risks and prioritise critical risks.
- Fewer than 20 workers: core duties apply to critical risks. WorkSafe says critical risks must be managed, not just identified.
- Welfare duties stay for everyone: toilets, drinking water, hand washing, first aid and emergency planning.
- Who counts: employees, contractors, subcontractors, labour hire, apprentices and regular volunteers.
Read our guide to the Health and Safety at Work Act and our article on the HSWA changes for 2027 for the full picture.
What are critical controls?
Critical controls are the controls a critical risk depends on: if one fails or is missing, serious harm becomes much more likely. The term is industry practice rather than a legal definition. The HSWA still requires you to eliminate the risk where reasonably practicable and to minimise it using the order of controls in GRWM regulation 6.
The order of controls when you can't eliminate a risk:
- Substitution, isolation or engineering controls: a less hazardous substance, a barrier between people and plant, an interlocked guard.
- Administrative controls: procedures, permits, exclusion zones and training.
- PPE: the last line, used for whatever risk remains.
Critical controls are often physical: edge protection, machine guarding, trench shoring, isolation of energy. Controls that rely only on people remembering a rule are weaker on their own.
Critical controls in different industries
Examples of critical risks and the controls they depend on:
- Construction: working at height, with edge protection or scaffolding inspected before use.
- Civil: trenches and excavations, with shoring or benching and a set exclusion zone.
- Manufacturing: moving machinery, with interlocked guarding and lockout before maintenance.
- Primary industries: quad bikes, tractors and chainsaws, with the right vehicle for the slope and training signed off before use.
- Automotive: vehicle hoists and pits, with locking devices checked before anyone goes underneath.
The Critical Control Framework and Hierarchy of Controls
The Critical Control Framework is a structured process used to systematically identify high-consequence hazards, establish reliable controls, and verify that those controls remain active and effective. This process relies heavily on the Hierarchy of Controls to ensure businesses apply the most effective safeguard reasonably practicable.
- Identify critical risks: Assess workplace operations to pinpoint activities with potential for fatal or life-altering outcomes based on historical incident data, severity, and exposure.
- Apply the hierarchy of controls:
- Elimination: Completely remove the hazard so the risk no longer exists (e.g., stopping hazardous work or eliminating dangerous chemicals).
- Substitution: Replace the hazard with a safer alternative (e.g., using less hazardous materials or safer equipment).
- Engineering Controls: Isolate workers from the hazard through physical modifications (e.g., machine guarding, isolation barriers, or local ventilation).
- Administrative Controls: Change work procedures, provide specialized training, mandate permits, or alter processes to minimize risk.
- PPE: Use personal protective equipment (e.g., safety glasses, harnesses, or hearing protection) as the last line of defense.
- Select critical controls: Isolate the essential controls within the hierarchy that directly prevent catastrophic failure.
- Monitor effectiveness: Implement routine, measurable verification processes to ensure controls remain active on-site every single day.
How do you prioritise critical risks?
To prioritise critical risks, manage them before other risks, review their controls more often and put more resources into them. WorkSafe's guidance for larger PCBUs uses these three elements, with examples such as engineered edge protection, interlocked guarding and routine checks that lockout and tagout is being done.
- List your critical risks: go through Schedule 1A and your own work. A dairy farm, a civil site and a joinery factory will have very different lists.
- Name the critical controls for each: what has to be in place every time before work starts.
- Give each control an owner: one named person, not "the team".
- Set a tighter review cycle: review critical controls more often than routine ones.
- Resource them first: budget, time and training go to critical risks before the rest.
Our step-by-step guide on how to do a risk assessment shows how to rate and record each one.
Do I still need critical risks under the Health and Safety Amendment Bill?
Yes, you do. Critical risks will become the primary legal focus of New Zealand's health and safety legislation.
Under the Health and Safety at Work Amendment Act 2026, which officially comes into force on 1 April 2027, critical risk management transitions from being an industry best practice to a formal legislative requirement.
- Refocused legal purpose: The updated Health and Safety at Work Act (HSWA) explicitly refocuses the health and safety system on identifying and managing critical risks - hazards capable of causing death, serious injury or illness, or notifiable events - rather than treating all low-level workplace risks equally.
- Small business rules (fewer than 20 workers): Smaller PCBUs will have a narrower set of duties. They are legally required to focus their primary health and safety compliance efforts specifically on critical risks, alongside providing basic welfare facilities.
- Larger business rules (20+ workers): Larger businesses must continue managing all workplace risks, but the new law mandates that critical risks must be formally prioritized above everyday hazards.
- Explicit statutory definition: The law introduces a clear statutory definition for critical risk, shifting the focus to whether serious harm would result if an incident occurs, rather than how likely the incident is to happen in the first place.
Instead of reducing your responsibilities, the April 2027 reform requires businesses to move away from generic tick-box paperwork for low-level hazards and establish clear, living controls for high-consequence critical risks.
How do you check critical controls are working?
You check critical controls by looking at the work, not the paperwork. WorkSafe's forestry code of practice suggests asking workers, reviewing incident and near miss reports, inspecting the site with a focus on control measures and scheduling audits. GRWM regulation 8 also requires a review whenever a control fails or the work changes.
- Before work starts: a short pre-start check that each critical control is in place.
- On site: a supervisor walk-around focused on the critical controls, not general housekeeping.
- After an event: every incident and near miss involving a critical risk triggers a review of its controls.
- For officers: a regular summary of critical risks, control checks and gaps, so directors can show due diligence.
WorkSafe also says lots of paperwork does not equal good health and safety. A one-page check the team does every day beats a binder nobody opens.
How Site App Pro helps with critical risks
Site App Pro helps you record your critical risks and keep evidence that your controls are checked.
- Digital hazard register: flag critical risks on the hazard board your team acknowledges on site.
- Scheduled control checks: set pre-starts and critical control checks with reminders when they are due.
- Reporting: export completed checks, incidents and corrective actions for officers, clients or an audit.
See how it works on the site safety features page.
Practical Implementation: Moving from paper to living evidence
Practical critical risk management requires businesses to transition away from static paper documents and annual check-boxes toward real-time, living evidence of safety compliance. Digital mobile platforms like health and safety apps allow site workers and managers to close the gap between what is documented on paper and what is verified in the field.
What to consider when switching from a paper to digital health and safety solution:
- Dynamic risk verification: Replace annual, static hazard registers with real-time digital hazard checks that update as job site conditions change throughout the day.
- Bridging the execution gap: Eliminate the dangerous gap between "documented controls" and "active controls" by verifying that safeguards are functioning on-site before work commences.
- Streamlining operations: Use a single, unified digital system for hazard identification, control verification, and audit trail collection rather than managing multiple disconnected systems.
- Defensible compliance: Provide company officers and directors with an automated, transparent, and defensible audit trail without placing excessive administrative burdens on frontline workers.
- Instant accessibility: Store custom digital forms, inductions, and critical task check-lists in one searchable platform accessible via mobile or desktop.